When investing, your capital is at risk and you may get back less than invested. Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.
Buy-Side vs Sell-Side Analysts
Buy-side and sell-side analysts are interrelated roles that help people and institutions make informed investment decisions. While there is a large overlapping skillset, they occupy separate positions within the broader financial industry.
QUOTE
I believe in analysis and not forecasting.
Big ideas
- Buy-side analysts work for investment firms that buy securities. They have an active and direct role in the management of client portfolios.
- A Sell-side analyst is a job held at an investment bank involved in the selling of securities. They have more of a passive and supportive role, advising clients on their investments.
- Buy-side careers can be found within portfolio management, private equity, venture capital, hedge funds, and sales. Sell-side positions can be found within investment banking, corporate finance, sales, and equity research.
Buy-side vs sell-side analysts: What’s the difference?
The difference is not so much the work they do but who they work for and thus the purpose of the work.
Buy-side analysts work for portfolio managers that buy securities on behalf of clients, usually as part of a pooled investment like a mutual fund or hedge fund.
Buy-side institutions make money by generating returns on the investments they manage, often earning fees based on the assets under management (AUM) and performance. Therefore, buy-side analysts are incentivised to provide accurate and insightful analysis to help their portfolio managers make profitable investment decisions.
Sell-side analysts work for brokerage firms and investment banks, providing research and recommendations to support (and encourage) their clients' trading and investment decisions.
Sell-side institutions make money through trading commissions, underwriting fees, and other transactional services. As a result, sell-side analysts are incentivised to produce research that generates trading activity and supports the sales and trading efforts of their firms.
Buy-side analysts work for portfolio managers that buy securities on behalf of clients, usually as part of a pooled investment like a mutual fund or hedge fund.
Buy-side institutions make money by generating returns on the investments they manage, often earning fees based on the assets under management (AUM) and performance. Therefore, buy-side analysts are incentivised to provide accurate and insightful analysis to help their portfolio managers make profitable investment decisions.
Sell-side analysts work for brokerage firms and investment banks, providing research and recommendations to support (and encourage) their clients' trading and investment decisions.
Sell-side institutions make money through trading commissions, underwriting fees, and other transactional services. As a result, sell-side analysts are incentivised to produce research that generates trading activity and supports the sales and trading efforts of their firms.
Both sets of analysts produce reports, make recommendations, and offer insights on market conditions, company performance, and industry trends.
The buy-side analyst's role and responsibilities
Like the sell-side analyst, the role of the buy-side analyst has morphed considerably over the years. The following are some of the main roles and objectives of the buy-side analyst.
1. Conducting in-depth research on investment opportunities
Buy-side analysts focus on identifying and analysing potential investment opportunities. They examine financial statements, industry trends, and economic data. Analysts use various tools to gather relevant information, providing a comprehensive view of a company's performance and prospects. This research helps in understanding the value and potential of different assets.
2. Evaluating potential risks and returns
Evaluating risks and returns is a key responsibility for buy-side analysts. They assess factors that could impact an investment’s performance, such as market conditions, regulatory changes, and company-specific issues. By comparing potential returns with associated risks, analysts help their firm make informed decisions about which investments to pursue.
3. Making investment recommendations for their firm
Based on their research and risk evaluations, buy-side analysts make recommendations on buying, holding, or selling assets. They present their findings to portfolio managers and other decision-makers within their firm. Their insights play a crucial role in shaping the firm’s investment strategy, aiming to maximise returns while managing risks effectively.
Main buy-side analyst duties
- Wealth management - monitoring and managing existing investments in the portfolio to align with investment strategy and risk tolerance.
- Research - conducting thorough research and analysis to identify potential investment opportunities using various tools.
- Analysis - analysing financial statements, industry trends, and market conditions to inform investment decisions. Evaluate portfolio risk/reward.
- Reporting - communicate investment decisions/recommendations to portfolio managers and clients.
- Industry engagement - engaging with company management and industry experts to gather insights that influence investment decisions.
- Client acquisition - find and retain clients to increase total assets under management.
The sell-side analyst's role and responsibilities
Sell-side analysts play more of a supportive and passive role that enables buy-side analysts to make investment decisions. However, they play an essential role that is not less than buy-side, just less obvious in many ways.
1. Providing research and recommendations to external clients
Sell-side analysts support external clients by delivering detailed research and investment recommendations. They share insights on stocks, bonds, and other financial instruments, aiming to help clients make informed decisions. These clients often include institutional investors, such as mutual funds and hedge funds, as well as individual investors.
2. Analysing companies and industries to identify investment ideas
Sell-side analysts scrutinise companies and entire industries to uncover promising investment opportunities. They study financial statements, market trends, and economic indicators. This analysis helps in spotting potential growth areas and undervalued assets, which can provide significant returns for their clients.
3. Delivering findings through reports and presentations
Sell-side analysts compile their research into comprehensive reports and presentations. They communicate their findings clearly and concisely to clients and other stakeholders. These reports often include buy, sell, or hold recommendations, along with the rationale behind these suggestions. Presentations help clients understand the analysts’ perspectives and make informed investment choices.
Main sell-side analyst duties
- Research - conducting thorough research and analysis on companies and industries to identify investment opportunities.
- Reporting - writing detailed research reports and notes to communicate findings and investment recommendations.
- Recommendations - making recommendations such as strong buy, neutral, or sell on specific companies/investments.
- Consultancy and advice - advise corporate clients for large transactions, mergers and acquisitions, etc.
- Financial modelling - developing financial models to forecast the future performance and valuation of companies.
- Investment opportunities - monitoring market trends, news, and developments to uncover potential investment opportunities.
- Transaction execution - assisting in executing financial transactions like IPOs and mergers, and building relationships with institutional investors and clients.
What is the sell-side vs buy-side process?
The sell-side and buy-side processes differ mainly in their goals and interactions with clients. Sell-side analysts serve external clients and generate revenue through commissions and fees. Buy-side analysts focus on internal portfolios, aiming to improve investment outcomes for their firm. Both roles require strong research skills and market knowledge but serve different purposes within the financial ecosystem.
- | Buy-side analyst | Sell-side analyst |
Clients | Portfolio managers within a firm, investment committees | Brokerages, institutions, retail investors |
Employers | Pension funds, hedge funds, mutual funds, banks, institutions, insurance companies, etc | Research departments, brokerage firms, and investment banks |
Research | Internal only | Publicly distributed |
Compensation | Salary + bonus based on portfolio performance | Salary + bonus based on research impact/distribution |
Focus | Broad market coverage | Detailed analysis of specific companies/sectors |
Aims | Recommendation for firms portfolio managers | Recommendations for external clients |
Sell-side process
Sell-side analysts are usually employed by investment banks and brokerage firms. They research companies and industries, and then provide recommendations to external clients. Their research reports help clients decide on investment actions like buying or selling stocks. Sell-side analysts also offer market commentary and host conference calls to discuss their findings.
Buy-side process
Buy-side analysts work for institutions like mutual funds, hedge funds, and pension funds. They focus on finding investment opportunities to benefit their firm’s portfolio. They conduct in-depth research, evaluate potential risks and returns, and make recommendations to their firm's portfolio managers. Their goal is to enhance their firm’s investment performance.
Specialised roles within buy-side and sell-side analysis
There are specialised roles within the buy-side and sell-side analysis industry. These roles focus on different aspects of investment and market analysis, enhancing the overall effectiveness of the financial industry.
Traders and portfolio managers on the buy-side
On the buy-side, portfolio managers and traders play crucial roles. Portfolio managers oversee investment strategies, selecting assets to maximise returns and manage risks. Traders execute the buying and selling of securities based on the portfolio manager's decisions. Their collaboration ensures that investment strategies are implemented effectively and efficiently, aiming for the best possible outcomes for their firm's clients.
Investment banking and sales teams on the sell-side
Sell-side firms have specialised teams such as investment banking and sales. Investment bankers help companies raise capital through public offerings, mergers, and acquisitions. Sales teams work to distribute the firm's research and investment products to clients, maintaining strong relationships with institutional investors. These roles are vital for facilitating market transactions and providing clients with valuable investment opportunities.
The evolving landscape of analyst specialisation
The landscape of analyst specialisation is constantly evolving. Analysts are now focusing on niche sectors and emerging markets to provide deeper insights. Technological advancements also lead to new roles, such as data analysts and quantitative researchers, who use big data and algorithms to inform investment strategies. This evolving specialisation allows firms to stay competitive and adapt to changing market dynamics.
Is a trader buy-side or sell-side?
A trader can be either buy-side or sell-side, depending on their role and employer. Buy-side traders work for institutions like mutual funds, hedge funds, and pension funds. They execute trades to benefit their firm’s investment portfolio, aiming to achieve the best possible execution to maximise returns.
QUOTE
The goal of a successful trader is to make the best trades. Money is secondary.
Sell-side traders, on the other hand, work for investment banks and brokerage firms. They execute trades on behalf of their clients, such as buy-side firms and individual investors. They also provide liquidity to the markets by buying and selling securities.
The main difference lies in who the trader serves. Buy-side traders focus on managing and growing their firm's own investments. Sell-side traders focus on executing trades and providing services for external clients. Both types of traders play essential roles in the financial markets, but their goals and responsibilities differ based on their position.
The main difference lies in who the trader serves. Buy-side traders focus on managing and growing their firm's own investments. Sell-side traders focus on executing trades and providing services for external clients. Both types of traders play essential roles in the financial markets, but their goals and responsibilities differ based on their position.
Collaboration between buy-side and sell-side analysts
Collaboration between buy-side and sell-side analysts is essential in the investment world. Sell-side analysts provide research reports, insights, and recommendations on various securities. Buy-side analysts use this information to help make informed investment decisions for their firms.
So the buy-side analysts rely on the sell-side research. The research is usually bought through soft dollars, which are additional fees to execute trades. These soft-dollar transactions are coming under scrutiny, however, and outright payment is becoming more common.
Regular communication between the two sides occurs through phone calls, meetings, and conferences. Sell-side analysts often host events where they present their findings and discuss market trends. Buy-side analysts attend these events to gain valuable insights and ask questions to clarify their understanding.
This interaction allows buy-side analysts to benefit from the extensive research and market knowledge of sell-side analysts. In return, sell-side analysts gain feedback on their research and understand the needs and interests of their buy-side clients. This ongoing exchange of information helps both sides refine their strategies and improve their performance in the financial markets.
Regular communication between the two sides occurs through phone calls, meetings, and conferences. Sell-side analysts often host events where they present their findings and discuss market trends. Buy-side analysts attend these events to gain valuable insights and ask questions to clarify their understanding.
This interaction allows buy-side analysts to benefit from the extensive research and market knowledge of sell-side analysts. In return, sell-side analysts gain feedback on their research and understand the needs and interests of their buy-side clients. This ongoing exchange of information helps both sides refine their strategies and improve their performance in the financial markets.
Transitioning between buy-side and sell-side roles
Transitioning between buy-side and sell-side analyst positions is possible and fairly common in the financial industry. Analysts may switch sides to broaden their skill set, pursue new challenges, or capitalise on different career opportunities. Usually, people start on the sell-side, gain exposure and "graduate" to the buy-side.
Moving from the buy-side to the sell-side allows analysts to leverage their market knowledge and investment expertise to provide insights and recommendations directly to clients. Conversely, transitioning from the sell-side to the buy-side involves focusing on managing portfolios and making investment decisions based on research received from sell-side analysts.
Both paths benefit from a deep understanding of financial markets and securities analysis, making the transition smoother. Analysts often bring valuable perspectives and insights gained from one side to the other, enriching their roles and contributing to better investment outcomes.
Overall, the ability to transition between buy-side and sell-side roles underscores the interconnectedness of financial markets and the versatility of analysts within them.
Moving from the buy-side to the sell-side allows analysts to leverage their market knowledge and investment expertise to provide insights and recommendations directly to clients. Conversely, transitioning from the sell-side to the buy-side involves focusing on managing portfolios and making investment decisions based on research received from sell-side analysts.
Both paths benefit from a deep understanding of financial markets and securities analysis, making the transition smoother. Analysts often bring valuable perspectives and insights gained from one side to the other, enriching their roles and contributing to better investment outcomes.
Overall, the ability to transition between buy-side and sell-side roles underscores the interconnectedness of financial markets and the versatility of analysts within them.
The impact of technology and automation on analyst roles
Technology and automation have transformed buy-side and sell-side analyst roles significantly. For buy-side analysts, automation enables the rapid processing of large datasets, improving decision-making and risk management. Algorithms and AI models help identify investment opportunities, enhancing portfolio performance.
On the sell-side, technology streamlines research and reporting processes. Automation tools assist analysts in analysing market trends and generating insights faster. This efficiency allows sell-side analysts to provide more timely and accurate recommendations to clients.
Additionally, technology facilitates better communication and collaboration between buy-side and sell-side analysts. Platforms for data sharing and virtual meetings enhance the exchange of information, making the research process more seamless.
On the sell-side, technology streamlines research and reporting processes. Automation tools assist analysts in analysing market trends and generating insights faster. This efficiency allows sell-side analysts to provide more timely and accurate recommendations to clients.
Additionally, technology facilitates better communication and collaboration between buy-side and sell-side analysts. Platforms for data sharing and virtual meetings enhance the exchange of information, making the research process more seamless.
Recap of buy-side vs sell-side analysts
Buy-side and sell-side analysts have different positions within the financial sector.
It is common for people to start on the sell-side and then "move up" to the buy-side, which offers greater compensation but requires more experience.
Yet this is only a general guideline - a sell-side investment banker can still make enormous amounts of money. Both sell-side and buy-side are huge multibillion-dollar fields with many subcategories and areas of specialisation.
Buy-side analysts rely on sell-side research to make investment decisions, but they tend to be more cautious. After all, it’s their necks in the noose if an investment goes south - not the sell-side. From this perspective, they have more skin in the game as active portfolio managers than sell-side research providers.
It is common for people to start on the sell-side and then "move up" to the buy-side, which offers greater compensation but requires more experience.
Yet this is only a general guideline - a sell-side investment banker can still make enormous amounts of money. Both sell-side and buy-side are huge multibillion-dollar fields with many subcategories and areas of specialisation.
Buy-side analysts rely on sell-side research to make investment decisions, but they tend to be more cautious. After all, it’s their necks in the noose if an investment goes south - not the sell-side. From this perspective, they have more skin in the game as active portfolio managers than sell-side research providers.
FAQ on buy-side vs sell-side analysts
Q: Are brokers sell-side?
Yes, brokers are considered sell-side. They facilitate transactions for clients, offering services like trading and research. Their role is to help clients buy and sell securities. Sell-side firms include investment banks and brokerages, providing advice and services to help clients make informed decisions. This is distinct from buy-side firms, which manage assets and make investments.
Q: What does a sell-side quant do?
A sell-side quant develops models and tools to analyse market data, helping brokers and traders make decisions. They create algorithms for pricing, trading strategies, and risk management. Their work supports trading desks by providing insights and solutions to improve performance and efficiency. This role involves a strong understanding of mathematics, statistics, and programming.
Q: What is an example of a buy-side analyst?
An example of a buy-side analyst is someone working at a mutual fund. They research and analyse stocks, bonds, and other securities to make investment recommendations. Their goal is to identify opportunities that will help the fund grow and outperform the market. They use financial models and data analysis to guide investment decisions for the fund's portfolio.
Q: What skills are essential for a successful sell-side analyst?
A successful sell-side analyst needs strong analytical skills, financial modelling expertise, and excellent communication abilities. They must understand market trends and be able to interpret financial statements. Writing clear and persuasive reports is essential. They should also have good relationship-building skills to interact with clients and colleagues effectively. Being proficient in using tools like Excel and financial databases is crucial.
Q: What is a sell-side analyst call?
A sell-side analyst call is when an analyst shares their insights and recommendations on a company or sector with clients. This can happen through a conference call or meeting. They present their analysis, answer questions, and provide updates on recent developments. The goal is to help clients make informed decisions based on the analyst's research and expertise.
- Mutual Funds: A professionally managed investment fund that pools money from multiple investors to buy a mix of stocks, bonds, or other assets.
- Hedge Funds: Investment funds that use advanced strategies, such as short selling and leverage, to maximise returns. They are typically available only to high-net-worth individuals and institutional investors.
- Assets Under Management (AUM): The total value of assets that a financial institution or fund manages on behalf of its clients.
- Public Offerings: The process of selling shares of a company to the public, usually through an Initial Public Offering (IPO) or a Secondary Offering.
- Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): The process of companies merging or one company purchasing another.
